About Us


Latest Reviews

View All Our Reviews

Tuscany Square Ristorante New Castle

3.9 Star Rating
3.9 stars - based on 5 Reviews

Bonnie F.
Ellwood City
1 1 Stars
Oct 28, 2016

Tuscany Square Ristorante New Castle

My review was for 2 stars not 4!

Bonnie F.
Ellwood City
4 4 Stars
Oct 28, 2016

Tuscany Square Ristorante New Castle

Very disappointing, in fact terrible. The only reason for 2 stars was because the pizza was pretty good, but that couldn't make up for the horrible wings. Dry, some parts hard to even chew. Nothing like what we've had in the restaurant. What makes bad wings worse the menu online says the wings cost $7.95 when I paid for them I was charged a little over $14.00 per dozen. It does not say on the menu how many you get for $7.95 if it had I would have adjusted the amount I got or not got them at all. $14.00 is a little excessive. Plus the celery for some unknown reason was placed under the wings so imagine hot food, stored in a warming oven, yes you get have cooked celery. Needless to say I will not be paying for another meal here. We stopped eating here after a few bad meals after a few years we gave it another shot. NO more.

Julie Opsitnik
new castle
2 2 Stars
Feb 15, 2014

Tuscany Square Ristorante New Castle

Had Valentines day dinner there last night...service was sub par and the dinner for two we chose was awful. ..we had the fillet steak dinner was not seasoned at all seasons and couldn't of been more than two ounces or so...think we paid $30 for a salad and potatoes I could of made this at home...further more cooks ate a customers meal at table next to us thinkin it was extra and our steak came out well done instead of medium rare and it looked like our steak was like it was cut from another peice of meat how unprofessional...very disappointed will not eat eat there again

8 people found this useful

Roberto P.
New Castle
5 5 Stars
Sep 9, 2013

Tuscany Square Ristorante New Castle

We love Italian Cousine and Tuscany Square Restaurant is our fav place to go. It is like mama used to cook for us at home. We even have them cater our family parties and special occasions throughout the year. When we go there they treat us like family and we really appreciate it. They are like family to us too.

3 people found this useful

Pauli B.
Beaver Falls, PA
5 5 Stars
Aug 1, 2013

Tuscany Square Ristorante New Castle

We celebrated here our anniversary because we got engaged at Tuscany Square Ristorante in New Castle. I will never for get that memorable evening when Lizzi said she would marry. I floated to the ceiling, or so it seemed. This was the best place to propose because we love the food, service and people here.

1 person found this useful

Business Overview

Year Established: 2001
Category: Restaurants
Tuscany Ristorante New Castle, Tuscany Restaurant New Castel, Italian food, lawrence county, mercer county, bar, bars, corporate party, family party, banquet room, family dining, fine cuisine, catering, pasta, seafood, lounge, sports bar, catering
Certifications / Awards:
  • Tuscany Square Ristorante is a Family Owned Italian Restaurant
  • Private Dining Room Accommodates Up to 200 People
  • Authentic Italian Cuisine, Steak and Seafood for over 10 years.
  • We will Host Your Private Parties or Business Functions.
  • Tuscany Square Ristorante is the Perfect Restaurant for Casual Dining Elegance, Business Dinners or Lunches, Special Occasions or Private Events.
  • Birthday Dinner- Birthday Party
  • Catering New Castle
  • Fine Dining
  • Seafood and Italian Cuisine
  • Banquet - Corporate Events
  • Italian Catering

Contact Us

  Call 724-654-0365 Today

  Fill out the Form or Call to:
  • For Corporate Parties New Castle PA
  • Reserve the Dining Room for 200 Guests
  • Reserve a Table for Fine Italian Cuisine

Incorrect please try again

Send Contact to My Cell Phone

Refer a Friend

Business Hours

Mon: Closed
Tue: Closed
Wed: Closed
Thu: Closed
Fri: Closed
Sat: Closed
Sun: Closed